OpinionCompulsory lifejackets or personal responsibility?

YACHT

 · 01.04.2023

Opinion: compulsory lifejackets or personal responsibility?
YACHT Week - The review

yacht/bullseye-yacht-woche-morten-2000x500_4fa89f0f09e320290436f689e31ba113

Dear readers,

From Sunday, the "Windstärke 10" museum in Cuxhaven will host the History of the lifejacket honoured. As early as the Middle Ages, buoyancy aids were made from animal skin tubes, but for a long time rather impractical and bulky cork belts and waistcoats were the life-saving device of choice.

It is doubtful whether Jack Dawson aka Leonardo DiCaprio would have saved his life with a lifejacket after the "Titanic" sank, but perhaps he could have given his beloved Rose one last gift. His lifejacket would have provided her or her descendants with a monetary life insurance policy: Lifejackets from the "Titanic" fetched up to 87,000 euros at auction, making them a good investment.

But shouldn't everyone wear a lifejacket, at least when they go out on the water?

After all, a lot has happened since the sinking of the "Titanic" in terms of the look and, above all, functionality of lifejackets. The latest generations can almost be seen as a fashion accessory on the catwalk, but also as a synonym for "It's dangerous where I'm going" - after all, even marines wear a lifejacket.

Or simply as proof of good seamanship with no ifs or buts? The discussion about a possible obligation to wear a vest has long been a hot topic in Germany. There are those who vehemently demand an obligation and put anyone in the dock who is seen on a ship without a waistcoat. And there are those on the other side who don't want to be told what to do and are in favour of personal responsibility.

Most read articles

1

2

3

There are seasoned offshore sailing professionals who consistently do without life jackets, as they would only prolong their suffering on the high seas with no chance of rescue. For the same reason, they say, the old sailors couldn't swim in the first place. The waistcoat can also be a hindrance when working on deck or in the mast and can even get caught.

How do you like this article?

But what about hobby sailors? The Tragic capsizing of the "Silja" in the North Sea reappraised as a result of which all three crew members went overboard and fought for their lives for hours. All three were wearing automatic waistcoats, which were badly damaged in the course of the capsizing and rescue, but nevertheless saved the lives of at least two sailors. In coastal waters with appropriate rescue options by sea rescuers, waistcoats are definitely life-prolonging and therefore also potential lifesavers, and not just because of this example.

Denmark, the country of my ancestors, is often cited as a good example of a functioning lifejacket-wearing obligation. After all, sailors and other water sports enthusiasts supposedly always wear a lifejacket there. But that's not true! There is an obligation to carry the required number of life jackets in the appropriate size on every watercraft - but wearing them is the responsibility of each individual, just like in Germany.

So what is right? Personal responsibility or compulsory lifejackets?

To be honest, I myself oscillate a little between the two worlds. As a skipper, I would always order my loved ones to wear a lifejacket at the latest when the wind picks up, and my young son always anyway. As a good role model, I would of course follow suit. Nevertheless, I would always like to be able to decide for myself whether or not to wear a lifejacket.

At the end of April, I will be transferring my boat, a Hanse 291, from Stralsund to my new home waters, the Flensburg Fjord. As I want to sail single-handed, I will be wearing my lifejacket right from the start - out of responsibility towards my family.

Morten Strauch, Editor YACHT

Newsletter: YACHT-Woche

Der Yacht Newsletter fasst die wichtigsten Themen der Woche zusammen, alle Top-Themen kompakt und direkt in deiner Mail-Box. Einfach anmelden:


Click to see through

The week in pictures:

The week began with a scare: Rosalin Kuiper suffered a head injury on board Boris Herrmann's "Malizia - Seaexplorer" ...
Photo: Antoine Auriol/Team Malizia/The Ocean Race

Recommended reading from the editorial team:

yacht/Myproject-122_588dd1e2bf08c53ce7f0b81757956597

THE OCEAN RACE

Always up to date- Daily updates

yacht/14-03-230320-juc-holcim-2965_488fc07f4470be34d3bcdb82f37ac20ePhoto: Julien Champolion/polaRYSE/Team Holcim-PRB/The Ocean Race

After Boris Herrmann's Team Malizia secured second place on part one of the third leg, an exciting duel with Holcim - PRB has developed at the top. Here on yacht.de you will find daily updates and background information on the race!


Project 412

Royal Huisman turns the hull of the 81-metre schooner

yacht/royal-huisman-trident-project-412-dji-20260319115941-0062-d_f5204e9b848fca2305bf3b3219600945

The Dutch shipyard Royal Huisman has reached an important milestone in the construction of the 81 metre long schooner with the project number 412. The aluminium hull was turned at the shipyard in Vollenhove. The flybridge three-master from the Trident 810 series will be delivered in 2028.


New podcast episode

How the Louisenlund boarding school supports young sailors

yacht/00-vorlage-podcast-artikel-teaserbild-01_4bfa4cab645a5303da19e94b34004753

Lessons, boarding school and sailing: these components come together in Louisenlund. In the YACHT podcast, foundation director Dr Peter Rösner and trainer Anna Schweizer talk about the school concept.


Whale off Niendorf

New rescue attempts - Killing not an option

yacht/583735748_b0971e80bad866cb219dd11551b29c1a

Fears for the humpback whale off Niendorf: the stranded whale is fighting for survival. Rescue attempts with a suction dredger failed. Killing is not an option. Experts are now hoping for larger equipment.


Navigation

GPS alternative Celeste - ESA launch on 25 March

yacht/celeste-iod-2-separating-from-electron-artist-impression_c6634e6818182a574bcfa3dc016ac8ed

Europe's GPS alternative gets a boost: ESA launches Celeste on 25 March with two satellites at an altitude of 510 kilometres. Galileo becomes more robust against jamming, indoor navigation possible. Frequency security critical until May.


Fit in old age

When is the end of sailing?

yacht/100200470_29398e081d555bb81108baf737421103

Sailing is possible well into old age. But the thought of stopping is part of it. When does it end? The answers are as individual as the sailors themselves.


Scandi 42

Performance deck saloon cruiser manages the balancing act in the test

yacht/yacht-20230308-202306-new-img-63-1_e34d3ecd99617544d61e9a373dc53bb7

A deck saloon bluewater yacht that consistently favours lightweight construction? And sails surprisingly agile? It sounds unusual, but it is. Scandi 42 in the test.


Denmark

Great Belt and Kattegat - News in the area

yacht/screenshot-2026-03-24-224132_0a41f3ce167a170ca037870f3c985e0a

Reviernews-Denmark 2026, Part 3: In the Great Belt northwards across the Kattegat to the Limfjord. There are also new developments in some harbours in the western part of the country.


Baltic Sea Protection Action Plan

Strict protection in three new areas with immediate effect

yacht/ostsee-f-gunkel_6f310be5204362a50f616fe7c9d3dc77

Three new marine protected areas in Schleswig-Holstein start from 24 March 2026: Where anchoring, fishing and speeding now have limits - and why the rules for sailors and motorboats are more lenient than feared.


Season start special

Out of the hall and onto the water!

YACHT Week: Season Star Special

The new season is finally starting. But before the boat returns to its usual element and sets off on its first trip, there are a few preparations to be made. The big season start guide for all to-dos!


Osmosis special

Recognising, treating and preventing osmosis - the complete guide

yacht/refit-delya-25-sandstahlen-osmose-wrede-2016-hsc-5421_d77d0f7cb7480f023adccd0d0d4d06f6

The term osmosis is associated with horror for many owners. Usually wrongly so. This special explains what osmosis is all about, when action is needed and how to prevent bladder disease


Newsletter: YACHT-Woche

Der Yacht Newsletter fasst die wichtigsten Themen der Woche zusammen, alle Top-Themen kompakt und direkt in deiner Mail-Box. Einfach anmelden:

Most read in category General service