OpinionThe most boring America's Cup of all time?

YACHT

 · 31.08.2024

Opinion: The most boring America's Cup of all time?
YACHT Week - The review

Dear readers,

Honestly, I'm looking forward to it. I'm really looking forward to some interesting duels. The 37th Americas Cup is coming up and the crews couldn't be more high-calibre. That has always been the case with the America's Cup. This year, however, Tom Slingsby, Peter Burling, Nathan Outtridge, Ben Ainslie, Jimmy Spithill, Paul Goodison and Quentin Delapierre really are the greatest of the present day. And that on their teams' spectacularly foiling AC75 machines. Nevertheless, I'm worried that the expected 1.5 billion spectators and I too could be disappointed by the event in the bay of Barcelona.

In our reporting, we have repeatedly spoken of the "probably most exciting cup ever" wrote. I must honestly admit that the Pre-regattas for the Louis Vuitton Cupwhich started on Thursday with the first race between the French and the Swiss, have dampened my expectations quite a bit. So far, the races have been more boring than exciting.

The races were too often too similar: the winner of the start wins at the end with a comfortable lead. Admittedly, this happens more often in match racing, as the leader can react calmly to his opponent. There is simply no danger of five boats on the other side of the course slipping through instead of the direct pursuer, as in fleet racing. It also makes sense that the skippers don't push themselves to the limit, especially in the pre-regattas, and risk their equipment for the slightest gap. Who wants that when you're sitting on a flying piece of carbon whipping across the water at around 100 km/h? Nevertheless, I expect the semi-finals and finals of the Challenger Selection Series in particular to be more exciting races and more intense battles for windward and leeward gates. These were simply too rare in the preliminary regattas.

Most read

1

2

3

4

5

The makers of the official YouTube broadcast also urgently need to work on their audio design. The mixing of ambient sound, onboard sound, the sailors' radio and the commentators was catastrophic and unworthy of the whole event. If this remains the case for the elimination races and the final race for the silver jug, it will certainly not succeed in getting new people interested in sailing. They would either have to follow the coverage without sound or sit in front of their screens with bleeding ears. Given the complexity of our sport, the former is certainly not possible, especially for newcomers, and the latter is not an option. This is certainly not what the organisers and, above all, the many sponsors involved in the Cup want.

The fact that the New Zealanders are cup defenders themselves have stipulated in the rules that they may participate in the qualifying regattas... without scoring points takes away my anticipation of the Cup. I'm not alone in this opinion: America's Cup veteran and North Sails President Ken Read also wrote in a commentary: "In my long-gone America's Cup days, there was an unwritten law that NOBODY trained WITH THE DEFENDERS. It was the 'all challengers against the defender' days. Full stop."

The Kiwis' participation allows them to make changes to the development of their boat while the others sail out the semi-finals and finals. And that's after they've sailed against all the teams in "real" races. It has always been a disadvantage for the challengers that they have not had the opportunity to sail direct races against the competition. I believe that breaking with tradition this year is a crucial flaw in the regulations of the 37th America's Cup. I fear that the Kiwis will be so far ahead of their rivals in the final that even these races will not be characterised by a great deal of excitement.

So there is still a lot for organisers and teams to do before the winner lifts the world's oldest sports trophy at the end of October. We can only hope that the challenging teams in particular will be able to make some positive adjustments before then.

I, for one, will continue to follow events closely and hope that things will get even more exciting!

Nils Leiterholt,

YACHT volunteer


Click on it to see through:

The week in pictures

Breathtaking beauty combined with breathtaking speed: the Italian AC75
Photo: Ian Roman/America's Cup

Recommended reading from the editorial team

yacht/Myproject-122_588dd1e2bf08c53ce7f0b81757956597

​SailGP Sassnitz

15,000 fans, a multi-million impact and plans up to 2030

yacht/fd2-5048_bebb2b2dd5b796bd2deeccb4ffd99a5f

15,000 fans, a new speed record and plans up to 2030: at the SailGP Sassnitz, the venue on Rügen was the real winner.


Ocean Race Atlantic

Live debut with Boris Herrmann’s “Malizia 4”

yacht/20260824-mlz-ny-arrival-ml-067_ab3606dc6f07fa586e4d964cf3b54e01

Will the 24-hour record be broken? Boris Herrmann’s new “Malizia 4” is one of the six IMOCs set to take part in the inaugural Ocean Race Atlantic on 1 September.


​Following a collision and engine failure

A ‘Steel Buddy’ brings the ‘Soggy Dollar’ home

yacht/1000142653_9c6b28fe615dab4bc04c39315b08a260

Engine failure off Heligoland: Sea rescue services tow the ‘Soggy Dollar’. A Steel Buddy then builds an unusual emergency diesel supply system.


Sophie Steinlein

Between Foils and Design Language

yacht/image00007_acb65e21c294d1887d94e44e62b3b5e0

Sophie Steinlein is setting her sights on the 2028 Olympics. In an interview with YACHT, the 49erFX helmswoman talks about making decisions at 50 knots, the balancing act between top-level sport and her studies, and the role of women in professional sailing.


Y6

The new luxury cruiser from Greifswald in front of the camera

yacht/yyachts-y6-exterior-11_0e6c361efc89996ac4e18bf84423f25f

The first pictures show the new Y6 from YYachts under sail. The gallery also offers a detailed look at the deck and the bespoke interior of this luxurious blue-water cruiser from Greifswald.


Baltic Sea

Remains of piles at a depth of just 1.5 metres – danger off Großenbrode

yacht/screenshot-2026-08-24-174222_771bccbf9a4217db8e6b4f9e7c134e62

A dangerous underwater obstacle has been discovered off the coast of Großenbrode: the remains of piles, lying just 1.5 metres below the surface – and this is a heavily trafficked stretch of water.


​Oyster 825 ‘Viva La Vida’

Capsized following severe keel damage

yacht/783981449-122246944316095413-3602582623290535968-n-firefly-upscaler-4x-skalierung_3ebda03607ca060b20e097761dfe193b

The Oyster 825 ‘Viva La Vida’ has capsized in Australia; the lower ballast section of the keel is missing. The incident is reminiscent of the ‘Polina Star III’, but the damage patterns differ significantly.


Linjett 36

The versatile Nordic boat in our test video, Part 2: What it’s like living on board.

yacht/linjett-36-test-2026-scheden-ngu-32_8f32eb4e7e11ca1c461d3847bea1116f

The second part of the video presentation on YACHT-TV takes us below deck on the Linjett 36: we show you the interior fit-out, layout, storage space and on-board technology, and take a detailed look behind doors, hatches and panelling.


100 years ago

YACHT 5/1926 – ‘Albert’-class cruising yacht

yacht/img-0476_8b3124e0e5699df5b821bb07802007fd

In issue 5/1926, the editorial team described the construction of a new vessel based on a shipyard class by Abeking & Rasmussen that was already 19 years old at the time. The “Albert class” was a cruising boat that had evolved from an early design for the metre class.


‘Pavane’

How a young boatbuilder saved a classic

yacht/100228498_c94aec02b9ebbc1b88c30066acc89d28

The ‘Pavane’ had been left neglected on land for years before the young boatbuilder Kyrell Becker took her on and restored her. Now, a new rig is set to give this classic Olin Stephens racer better performance in light winds.



Newsletter: YACHT-Woche

Der Yacht Newsletter fasst die wichtigsten Themen der Woche zusammen, alle Top-Themen kompakt und direkt in deiner Mail-Box. Einfach anmelden:

Please note: Our newsletters are currently only available in German.

Share article:

Most read in category General service