OpinionAIS services on the Internet - a blessing or a curse?

YACHT

 · 01.06.2024

Opinion: AIS services on the Internet - a blessing or a curse?
YACHT Week - The review

Dear readers,

If you have AIS on board, you will probably love it. Being able to see information such as the position, course and speed of other ships in the vicinity on the plotter is often worth its weight in gold when you're underway.

The technology is a blessing, especially when sailing in busy areas, for example in the triangle between Helgoland, Cuxhaven and the Weser on the North Sea. This is where busy commercial shipping lanes meet and dozens of big ships lie in the roadstead. Being able to follow their journey on the motorway of the ocean liners is great. Functions such as CPA and TCPA allow you to adjust your own course and speed with foresight.

That alone would provide safety, but investing a few hundred euros more in a device that also transmits pays off at sea. Sailors repeatedly report how the crew of a freighter changed course minimally long before a very close passage could occur, so that everything remains relaxed for both sides.

The flip side of the coin of active AIS: everyone else is also live. Online services such as Marinetraffic or Vesselfinder transmit the data of the transmitting ships on the Internet almost in real time. Anyone who knows which boat name they are looking for will find it. They can see where a club mate, friend, famous boat or fleeting sailing acquaintance is currently sailing.

Quite a few (long-distance) sailors manage a AIS transponder are now available for this purpose: So that friends and family at home can travel along virtually and know where the crew is.

But an encounter during a cruise in the Swedish archipelago last year showed me that it's not just people you know who follow you: in the evening at anchor, a man paddled up to our boat in a small sailing dinghy, quickly climbed on board and introduced himself by saying that he had been watching us for a few days. He asked us what the water depth was like in the small harbour we had been in the day before.

We had a chat and he left. But the realisation remained that we were making ourselves transparent and that complete strangers were obviously interested in our route. Now it's debatable whether you have to sail through the archipelago with an active AIS or whether it's better to use it on shipping lanes. But then also consistently. On the way back from this trip, we spotted a sailor a few miles ahead of us in the southern Baltic Sea who only ever transmitted when a large vessel appeared on his course. This on and off was rather irritating for other road users.

Of course, marine traffic and the like can also be very useful sources of information for trip planning: You can discover anchorages or guess what the conditions might be like by interpreting the course and speed of boats at sea.

However, I wonder when all those who have purchased an active AIS allowed (commercial) online services such as Marinetraffic to transmit their position to the internet and make it available to the whole world. This doesn't have much to do with the actual purpose - better collision prevention between ships at sea.

Kristina Müller,

YACHT editor

Newsletter: YACHT-Woche

Der Yacht Newsletter fasst die wichtigsten Themen der Woche zusammen, alle Top-Themen kompakt und direkt in deiner Mail-Box. Einfach anmelden:

Please note: Our newsletters are currently only available in German.

Click on it to see through:

The week in pictures

As if untamed: "Malizia - Seaexplorer" leaves New York before the start of the New York Vendée
Photo: Mark Lloyd / Alea

Recommended reading from the editorial team

yacht/Myproject-122_588dd1e2bf08c53ce7f0b81757956597

Malizia 4

First the damage to the foil, now the mainsail has torn

yacht/261007-champolion-malizia-841_c06b8a0b0105b29220ee86f3f10a8107

First the damage to the foil, then broken hull reinforcements, and now a tear in the mainsail. Two new videos show how Team Malizia is repairing and further developing the IMOCA ahead of the Route du Rhum.


Silting up of the Elbe

Small ports are fighting for every metre of water depth

yacht/100226754_cc5dabaf4f4f82a167e1f0282e35d759

The Lower Elbe is silting up, time windows are shrinking and ports are becoming difficult to reach. With flat-bottomed boats and homemade dredgers, sailors are fighting to preserve their fishing grounds.


Propulsion

Max Bianchi variable-pitch propeller, which adjusts its pitch whilst the aircraft is in flight

yacht/max-prop-03_d71c162431257fcf66b1a95a9046dad2

A variable-pitch propeller that automatically adjusts its pitch whilst in flight: this is what Max Prop’s Max Bianchi model is designed to achieve in powered flight and motor-sailing.


Interview

What is it like to work on board the ‘Thor Heyerdahl’?

yacht/00-vorlage-podcast-artikel-teaserbild-2026-6_11b1c7a8a0dcb778cfd557b3041e5f6e

The ‘Thor Heyerdahl’ has been sailing the world’s oceans for more than 40 years. YACHT editor Fabian Boerger explains why this historic vessel remains relevant.


Hurricanes 2026

Dramatic rescue off the coast of California – El Niño shapes the storm season

yacht/screenshot-2026-10-13-115041_64230bb6c91709fa2abf7f09494f4bee

A lifeguard rescues a sailor from a partially flooded yacht off the coast of California. Why the 2026 hurricane season is turning out so differently between the Atlantic and the Pacific.


Blue-water yachts

These five are heading to the ends of the earth

yacht/te-der-20-tonner-immer-wieder-zweistellige-werte-durchs-wasser-und-blieb-dabei-die-ruhe-selbst_f3068a158d6522ee5c589c0c35a736e1

Five blue-water yachts, five designs: the Boréal 56, Kraken 58, Pure 49, Stem 50 and Breehorn 55 demonstrate their strengths and weaknesses on a long-distance voyage.


Record low water level in Lake Zurich

Sailing yacht flown by helicopter to its winter storage facility

yacht/yacht-in-der-luft_05131d03241c95e263d11ca6f8cfe3ac

Water levels in Lake Zurich are below the previous record low. Because his sailing yacht was stuck in the shallow water and in danger of capsizing, a 65-year-old owner had his boat airlifted out by helicopter. The operation cost around 2,000 francs and highlights just how much the exceptionally low water level is now affecting navigation.


Series of thefts continues

Thieves make off with two 300 PS outboard motors from Wieltsee

yacht/7b70726e-0143-47d1-a536-7c33bb106b0e_3204fffa58099a1681b4a9abad958e1d

Thieves have struck again at Wieltsee: they have stolen two boats and removed heavy outboard motors. This is already the fourth such incident in three months.


Second-hand boat of the week

Arietta 31 – the dawn of an era

yacht/p1150741_760582d5c30e30dfa0fc0c0ed46a0882

A narrow waist, mahogany hull and elegant overhangs: the Arietta 31, designed by Olle Enderlein, prioritises balanced lines and seaworthiness over maximum living space. As a forerunner of later Scandinavian cruising yachts, it is now an interesting classic for sailors seeking a traditional, compact cruising yacht.


Breehorn 55 review

Is it the ideal home at sea?

yacht/m-verglast-hier-sitzt-man-bequem-zusammen-mit-mehreren-personen-mit-freier-sicht-nach-draussen_33f438de0ebff79c172bd9ce3671d65b

A pilothouse, teak fittings and an unusually accessible service tunnel: this is how the Breehorn 55 works below deck, and these compromises remain.



Newsletter: YACHT-Woche

Der Yacht Newsletter fasst die wichtigsten Themen der Woche zusammen, alle Top-Themen kompakt und direkt in deiner Mail-Box. Einfach anmelden:

Please note: Our newsletters are currently only available in German.

Share article:

Most read in category General service