Corona crisisLawsuits against harbour closures

Lasse Johannsen

 · 23.04.2020

Corona crisis: lawsuits against harbour closuresPhoto: YACHT/N. Krauss
Police boat checks compliance with marina closures. Many an owner has felt like a criminal in the past few weeks when he has wanted to check on his property.
The Schleswig Higher Administrative Court is dealing with the question of whether the closure of marinas is a breach of the constitution

According to information from YACHT online, two applications for judicial review were received yesterday by the Schleswig-Holstein Higher Administrative Court in Schleswig. A harbour operator and a berth holder are contesting the general closure of recreational boat harbours in accordance with Section 6 (3) No. 8 of the Schleswig-Holstein State ordinance on measures to combat the spread of the novel coronavirus SARS-CoV-2 and the previous practice of closing ports by decree even without this explicit regulation.

A decision by the court is not expected until after the opening of the ports, which was announced by the state government for 4 May subject to conditions. Port operators are nonetheless awaiting the clarification of this legally sensitive issue with great hope, as it will determine whether claims for damages can be asserted against the state.

However, many users of the mostly municipal marinas are annoyed because it is to be feared that they may only be visited by the children of the state for the time being. The ban on entry for "tourist purposes" is likely to remain in place beyond 4 May. Non-resident berth holders will then be asked to pay by their landlord, the state of Schleswig-Holstein, but will be prevented from using the rented property. Frustration has been mounting since yesterday, particularly because owners of second homes will be prevented from entering the country from 4 May. allowed again should be.

Share article:
Lasse Johannsen

Lasse Johannsen

Deputy Editor in Chief YACHT

Born in Kiel, grew up on the water and on board, trained as a sailor in the club and sailing on the North and Baltic Seas. After school, navy and legal training, he worked as a trainee at YACHT from 2007-2009 in the Panorama department, which he now heads. He is also responsible for the special edition of YACHT classic, has published several books with Delius-Klasing and is deputy editor-in-chief of YACHT. Johannsen is an enthusiastic cruising sailor on his own keel and an active supporter of the German classic boat scene.

Most read in category Special