America's CupAllegations of embezzlement off the table: Kiwis back on course

Tatjana Pokorny

 · 25.08.2020

America's Cup: Allegations of embezzlement off the table: Kiwis back on coursePhoto: Emirates Team New Zealand
The first New Zealand AC75 yacht "Te Aihe" in training
A government investigation into the finances of the America's Cup organisers and Emirates Team New Zealand has concluded: There was "no impropriety"

The New Zealand America's Cup organisers (ACE) and Emirates Team New Zealand (ETNZ) can once again focus on their actual tasks: hosting the 36th America's Cup and defending the oldest sporting trophy in the sailing world - which presents enough challenges in times of the coronavirus pandemic. Following an extensive investigation by financial investigators from the government-commissioned agency Beattie Varley, the domestic Cup dominators have been cleared of any allegations of misappropriation of state funds or even personal enrichment.

  Can breathe again after many weeks of tension on the financial front: Grant Dalton, CEO of Emirates Team New ZealandPhoto: Emirates Team New Zealand Can breathe again after many weeks of tension on the financial front: Grant Dalton, CEO of Emirates Team New Zealand

The New Zealand Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment (MBIE) has completed its investigation into allegations against Emirates Team New Zealand Limited and the America's Cup Limited organisation in consultation with Auckland City Council as host partner. The outcome was released today with a joint statement from all parties. The Beattie Varley Report found that there was "no evidence of financial impropriety or misappropriation of government funds". The investigation also found that there was "no loan from ACE to ETNZ and no fraudulent behaviour on the part of ACE or ETNZ". No "Crown money" was used for personal expenses of team boss Grant Dalton. Overall, there was "no financial impropriety of any nature".

Most read articles

1

2

3

4

5

  A matter of national interest in New Zealand: the America's Cup. Which is why the state authorities are also interested in the correct use of their sponsorship money. Here is one of the many triumphant pictures of the Kiwis after the last Cup victory with team boss Grant Dalton, skipper Glenn Ashby (centre) and helmsman Peter BurlingPhoto: Carlo Borlenghi A matter of national interest in New Zealand: the America's Cup. Which is why the state authorities are also interested in the correct use of their sponsorship money. Here is one of the many triumphant pictures of the Kiwis after the last Cup victory with team boss Grant Dalton, skipper Glenn Ashby (centre) and helmsman Peter Burling

However, there was also a rebuke from the ministry's managing director. However, Caroly Tremain remained vague in her criticism: "While it is excellent news that there were no financial improprieties and the escalation process has now come to an end, the Beattie-Varley report also contains some concerns about the records relating to various historical matters." The government investigation began when allegations against the organisers of the 36th America's Cup became public. The controversy was preceded by internal disputes and recriminations. As a result, Beattie Varley was commissioned to carry out an intensive investigation because the state authorities were concerned about the legitimate use of their funds.

Insights into the design for the new AC75 flying yachts, whose design financing is also at issue in New Zealand

The America's Cup not only has the status of a leading national sport in New Zealand, but is also regarded as an important economic factor and is therefore subsidised with millions in state funds. Caroly Tremain said: "The America's Cup is an important event for Auckland and for New Zealand. Even more so as we struggle through and recover from the effects of Covid-19. I look forward to working closely with ACE to deliver a world-class event that we can all be proud of." At the same time, Carolyn Tremain announced the imminent continuation of the agreed government funding.

However, one disagreement remains and should now be resolved as quickly as possible at the green table. The issue at stake is funding for the "AC36 event and design costs of the class" and whether or not these costs - estimated by various media at around 1.7 million euros - should be borne by the organisers and therefore ultimately by state funds. The parties have already agreed on an arbitration procedure.

  The cradle of the America's Cup: its history began in August 1851 with "The R.Y.S. £100 Cup". After 169 years, it is still the supreme discipline of high-performance sailingPhoto: America's Cup The cradle of the America's Cup: its history began in August 1851 with "The R.Y.S. £100 Cup". After 169 years, it is still the supreme discipline of high-performance sailing

For ETNZ CEO Grant Dalton, the review was also about the now successful defence against accusations that he had taken personal advantage of team funds. The team boss also said: "With the departure of the previous event managers, we have undertaken a thorough review of our personnel. We now have the team that can deliver the event. We have recruited experienced and respected event professionals to lead the preparations for the event."

Away from the internal New Zealand disputes with possible external repercussions, two teams have trained in the former and future Cup venue for the first time in recent weeks: In addition to Emirates Team New Zealand with helmsman Peter Burling, US challenger American Magic was also part of the impressive muscle show. The British and Italians are expected next in Auckland. The relocation of the teams, each with more than a hundred employees and some with families, is not easy during the coronavirus pandemic.

Click here for the detailed Beattie Varley Report here.

  Two Cup teams are already training before Auckland: Emirates Team New Zealand and American MagicPhoto: America's Cup Two Cup teams are already training before Auckland: Emirates Team New Zealand and American Magic

The New Zealanders released this clip after their first clash with the American Magic's American challengers at Hauraki Golf

Share article:
Tatjana Pokorny

Tatjana Pokorny

Sports reporter

Tatjana “tati” Pokorny is the author of nine books. As a reporter for Europe's leading sailing magazine YACHT, she also works as a correspondent for the German Press Agency (DPA), the Hamburger Abendblatt and other national and international media. In summer 2024, Tatjana will be reporting from Marseille on her ninth consecutive Olympic Games. Other core topics have been the America's Cup since 1992, the Ocean Race since 1993, the Vendée Globe and other national and international regattas and their protagonists. Favorite discipline: Portraits of and interviews with sailing personalities. When she started out in sports journalism, she was still intensively involved with basketball and other sports, but sailing quickly became her main focus. The reason? The declared optimist says: “There is no other sport like it, no other sport with such interesting and intelligent personalities, no other sport so diverse, no other sport so full of energy, strength and ideas. Sailing is like a constantly refreshing declaration of love for life."

Most read in category Regatta